How Subpoenas Work in The Russia Investigation
Stanford, 27 Jan 18
       

(Credit: Getty Images)

Investigations by Congress and special counsel Robert Mueller looking into whether the Russian government interfered with the 2016 US presidential election took a dramatic turn last week when Steve Bannon, former chief strategist to President Trump, refused to comply with a subpoena from the US House Intelligence Committee to answer questions about his time in the White House.

Here, David Sklansky, professor of law and faculty co-director of the Stanford Criminal Justice Center, discusses subpoenas and the law governing these investigations. Sklansky is also the author of Democracy and the Police (Stanford University Press, 2008), and he writes regularly about criminal procedure and law enforcement.


Q: Earlier this week Bannon made headlines when he refused to answer questions put to him by members of the US House Intelligence Committee.

That refusal resulted in the quick issuance of a subpoena during the meeting, yet he still refused to answer key questions, evidently citing executive privilege. What do you make of his reason for not complying with that subpoena?

A: Apparently Bannon refused, on instructions from the White House, to answer any questions about anything that happened during the transition or after Trump took office. That’s further than any remotely plausible interpretation of executive privilege would reach. And it’s a position that would mean that there could never be any meaningful congressional oversight of the executive branch, or of presidential transitions.

It’s not clear that executive privilege applies to presidential transitions at all.  And even after a president takes office, executive privilege is limited. It gives way, for example, when there is a strong need for the evidence in question. And as far as we know the White House hasn’t asserted executive privilege in connection with any of what Bannon would testify about. So this really is just stonewalling. I don’t think Congress should go along with it. And it doesn’t look as though they will.

Q: Special Counsel Mueller subpoenaed Bannon to appear before a grand jury this week. Why was he subpoenaed?

A: We can’t know for sure, because Mueller and his team have been admirably close-lipped about their investigation. But Mueller is charged with investigating ties between the Trump campaign and Russia, as well as any related efforts to obstruct justice. Bannon helped run Trump’s campaign and then was a top official in the White House. So it’s completely understandable that Mueller would have questions for him.

Q: It was also reported that Bannon will now cooperate with special counsel Mueller. Does that mean that he won’t have to go before the grand jury?

A: Yes, probably. It’s common in a federal criminal investigation for prosecutors to agree to conduct an office interview with a witness in lieu of questioning the witness before a grand jury. Depending on the terms of Bannon’s agreement with the prosecutors, though, it’s still possible that he may wind up testifying before a grand jury down the road.

Q: Why would Bannon comply with Mueller’s subpoena and not the one issued by the House?

Sign in to view full article

       
How Robots Can Help Us Embrace a More Human View of Disability
When dealing with the otherness of disability, the Victorians in their shame built huge out-of-sight asylums, and their legacy of ...
Thusha Rajendran
Tue, 9 May 17
From ‘White Flight’ to ‘Bright Flight’ – The Looming Risk for Our Growing Cities
If the growth of cities in the 20th century was marked by “white flight”, the 21st century is shaping up ...
Jason Twill
Fri, 19 May 17
Enough’s Enough: Buying More Stuff Isn’t Always the Answer to Happiness
The average German household contains 10,000 items. That’s according to a study cited by Frank Trentmann in his sweeping history ...
Anthony James
Thu, 5 Jan 17
Explainer: How The Brain Changes When We Learn To Read
Right now, you are reading these words without much thought or conscious effort. In lightning-fast bursts, your eyes are darting ...
Nicola Bell
Thu, 18 May 17
How To Calculate The Economic Impact Of Grief
The death of a child is one of the most traumatic experiences that a parent can experience. Those who do ...
Gerard Van den Berg
Sat, 14 Jan 17
At Epoch Times, We Care :o)
An Epoch Times Survey
An Epoch Times Survey
BUCHERER
Sports Elements
Sports Elements